This analysis is outdated. Please reanalyze.

Pros & Cons

Update Pros and Cons
The AI used to provide these results are constantly improving. These results might change.

Pros

Every one of the stories reads like an original by hodgson himself. Lark hill barrow is one of my favorites, but even the dark twist in lusitania still lingers in my memory.

Was this feature helpful?

Highlights

The AI used to provide these results are constantly improving. These results might change.

Quality


Very much in keeping with the style and era of the original, while making full use of meikle's writing prowess.


Better than the originals in some places.


Sometimes the cases are real but manageable; sometimes completely fake, and sometimes so dangerous that carnacki would have die...  Read More


His famous electric pentacle, the “sigsand manuscript," and the powerful “unknown last line of the saaamaaa ritual" are used by...  Read More

Competitiveness


A pitch perfect homage to the original carnacki.

Overview

  • How are reviewers describing this item?
    original, dark, found, last and best.
  • Our engine has profiled the reviewer patterns and has determined that there is minimal deception involved.
  • Our engine has determined that the review content quality is high and informative.
  • Our engine has discovered that over 90% high quality reviews are present.
  • This product had a total of 121 reviews as of our last analysis date on Aug 21 2024.

Helpful InsightsBETA

The AI used to provide these results are constantly improving. These results might change.

    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    This past fall i was looking for some chilling reading for the advent of the dark season


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    I read some good books but nothing really fulfilled what i was longing for


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    And then i found william meikles carnacki stories


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    I had read the original hodgson stories years ago and found them good but probably more entertaining in their own day


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    Meikles stories while true to the originals were more enjoyable i thought


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    The stories vary between cursed objects to the threats of great cosmic horrors


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    It follows the same formula every time


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    The narrator is invited to carnackis place for a story

Review Count History
Loading...

Add Fakespot to your browser, Secure Shopping on the go.

Supported on Amazon, eBay, Walmart, Bestbuy, and many more.

Download Fakespot for Browsers
Download for the Chrome Web store
Download for Firefox Addons
1 million plus shoppers trust Fakespot