Dr scholl’s insole are the best, provides support on my heels and arc. I have extremely flat feet (suction cups on wet tile flat), and these give my feet adequate support and comfort when i walk or jog. Ish miles is a breeze.

Bada bing bada boom. I change them out every 2 to 4 years, so this was my refresh. If you’re not pounding pavement as much, they probably hold up longer.

These inserts compress quite a bit. The inserts are very spongy and don't provide solid support. These shipping inconsistencies along with bad orders make me question renewing my membership.

The smell is not as bad now, but it hasn't disappeared. They seem worn and very cheaply put together. The poor quality of the manufacturing makes me confident that these won't last very long. Very expensive for a thin piece of foam and not much else.

The insole does not replace the insole already in the footwear. They are also much too wide for my average-width feet, and didn't fit in most of my (women's) shoes, even the comfy flats and athletic shoes.