The proportions are a little odd if you’re not at least as tall as the model in the picture i imagine at least 5’10 the length is fine for me at an extra small just above the knee barely but the waist is a little short and sits just a little above my true waist i was afraid the small would be longer than the knees or kind of loose for wearing a sweater over and i think i was right i specifically wanted a winter dress that would look good with both long and short boots and i’m just not tall enough to look good with long boots and a skirt at or below the knee i am 5’3 small frame and a little busty so that might factor in otherwise a perfect fit under sweaters really warm with a slip underneath and i think it’ll look great with boots and tights