Pros & Cons

Update Pros and Cons
The AI used to provide these results are constantly improving. These results might change.

pros

See Details

pros

Features with many positive mentions

See Details

Long-Lasting

Customers are highly satisfied with the long-lasting nature of this Maybelline New York Eyeliner. They appreciate that it doesn't smudge or budge throughout the day, even for those with oily eyes.

Smooth Application

Customers are highly satisfied with the smooth application of Maybelline New York Eyeliner. They find it easy to apply and glides on smoothly without smudging or running, making it perfect for creating precise lines. Some customers also appreciate its long-lasting finish and ability to blend for a smoky effect. However, a small number of customers have reported that the eyeliner can be too soft and may need to be set quickly before it sets, or that it can irritate their eyes if used as an eyeliner.

Was this feature helpful?

Highlights

The AI used to provide these results are constantly improving. These results might change.

Quality


This was great, could smudge as an eyeliner on lower lash line, work quickly before it sets and it will stay.


Maybelline tattoo eyeliners are fantastic if you want a long lasting finish, this colour is dark enough without being too dark ...  Read More


This product burns the eye if used as a liner.


Its so horrible and will give you an irritating dull feel.

Price


This is just as good for a fraction of the cost.


Thought this would take a while to come but was here quicker than estimated,i like the colour as i have brown eyes and black fo...  Read More

Competitiveness


So far no breakages which i appreciate since i bought the same brand in black and the tip had broken off.


Only ever found one other brand of pencil that didn't sting and stayed on my upper waterline - but it was expensive and after y...  Read More

Overview

  • How are reviewers describing this item?
    good, colour, easy, great and soft.
  • Our engine has profiled the reviewer patterns and has determined that there is minimal deception involved.
  • Our engine has discovered that over 90% high quality reviews are present.
  • This product had a total of 14,550 reviews as of our last analysis date on Dec 15 2024.

Helpful InsightsBETA

The AI used to provide these results are constantly improving. These results might change.

    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    Ive got the kind of skin that breaks makeup down quickly including eye makeup


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    Nice eyeliner but when sharpened the charcoal is very fragile and easily breaks


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    Not harsh on the eyelid to use nice colour


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    But its not a twist to sharpen


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    You need to sharpen with good sharpener


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    Its easy to use and doesnt smudge easily


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    I’ve used numerous high end eyeliners but they always smudge into my lower lash and mess up my eye makeup


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    I have been struggling with eyeliner smudging under my eyes

Review Count History
Loading...
Price History
Loading...

Add Fakespot to your browser, Secure Shopping on the go.

Supported on Amazon, eBay, Walmart, Bestbuy, and many more.

Download Fakespot for Browsers
Download for the Chrome Web store
Download for Firefox Addons
1 million plus shoppers trust Fakespot