This analysis is outdated. Please reanalyze.

Ask Fakespot Chat questions about this productAlpha

Initializing Fakespot Chat

error

System error,

Loading suggested questions

Suggested Questions

athena-arrow

Suggested Questions

No suggested questions were found

Please note: The content is generated by an AI language model based on reviews. We are constantly improving the accuracy, however, its outputs may contain errors or offensive content from certain reviews. Please report any errors or offensive content to us. Also, please note that we will not collect your questions unless you click the thumbs up/down button to provide feedback. The answers displayed will be stored by us so if another Fakespotter asks a similar question we can provide them an answer faster. Your feedback will only help us make Fakespot Chat better! By using Fakespot Chat, you agree to Fakespot's terms of use and privacy notice.

Pros & Cons

Update Pros and Cons
The AI used to provide these results are constantly improving. These results might change.

Pros

Easily holds the weight of a 13-14 well-loaded pizza without deforming when putting on/taking out. I no longer trust any other baking sheet but these, they have never wronged me. My silicone baking mats fit almost perfect on top and made it easy to th...  Read More

Bright silver keeps your cookies from scorching on the bottom! All edges are smooth and well finished and the sheet is sturdy. Performs fine, but that's an odd side effect. I have this item on my place at the dining room table, so that all spills just...  Read More

The heat distributes evenly throughout the macarons. Easy to clean, sleek minimalist design is a plus.



Cons

The product was advertised as a 16 inch pan. The advertised measuements are not correct. This cookie sheet is too large for my oven. The baking sheet is a much better product with rounded edges and stronger aluminum.

The oddest thing is that the bottom of my cookies won't brown. It's extremely light and flimsy. I generally like nordic ware products, so it's really disappointing.

Was this feature helpful?

Highlights

The AI used to provide these results are constantly improving. These results might change.

Quality


The lip is easy to grab and the metal is well polished as well.


With its natural aluminum construction, it provides even heating and browning, and its durable material can withstand hot tempe...  Read More


Bent edges keep these from warping while baking and stay flat.


Very thin metal, so if you like insulated don't purchase this one.

Price


For the price i'd imagine this is the best you can get.


A pan like this to cook pizza is hard to find although it is a little pricey.

Shipping


It’s an xmas present :) and it came super fast!


Arrived timely and exactly what i wanted.

Packaging/appearance


Arrived in perfect condition, well packaged, no dents or scratches.

Competitiveness


In comparison, traditional half sheet pans measure 18”x13” so only two sheets fit in my fridge and none will fit in my freezer.


And because it is made in the usa, i trust the manufacturing process much more than i would if it were made in china.

Helpful InsightsBETA

The AI used to provide these results are constantly improving. These results might change.

    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    I ruined my wifes favorite cookie sheet and was in charge of replacing it with one as good


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    Hers was flat aluminum had no coatings didnt warp and would fit in her smaller oven


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    The cookies come out as well as her old one


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    The material is a little thinner than i had expected though not sure how long it will hold up


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    I own two of these and wanted a third


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    Very poor shipping procedure item shipped in a plastic bag and one corner was bent


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    I will pound it into shape with a hammer


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    Should have been in a carton amazon knows better

Review Count History
Loading...
Price History
Loading...

Ask Fakespot Chat questions about this productAlpha

Initializing Fakespot Chat

error

System error,

Loading suggested questions

Suggested Questions

athena-arrow

Suggested Questions

No suggested questions were found

Please note: The content is generated by an AI language model based on reviews. We are constantly improving the accuracy, however, its outputs may contain errors or offensive content from certain reviews. Please report any errors or offensive content to us. Also, please note that we will not collect your questions unless you click the thumbs up/down button to provide feedback. The answers displayed will be stored by us so if another Fakespotter asks a similar question we can provide them an answer faster. Your feedback will only help us make Fakespot Chat better! By using Fakespot Chat, you agree to Fakespot's terms of use and privacy notice.

Add Fakespot to your browser, Secure Shopping on the go.

Supported on Amazon, eBay, Walmart, Bestbuy, and many more.

Download Fakespot for Browsers
Download for the Chrome Web store
Download for Firefox Addons
1 million plus shoppers trust Fakespot