It has some very cool surprises, choose your own adventure moments, and the production quality is great.

It has some very cool surprises, choose your own adventure moments, and the production quality is great.  Read Less

We are almost done with the full campaign and it has definitely taken some time.

We are almost done with the full campaign and it has definitely taken some time.  Read Less

There are also many suggested variants that can smooth out some of the complaints people have had with the rules as written.

There are also many suggested variants that can smooth out some of the complaints people have had with the rules as written.  Read Less

There are issues with the rules and not everything in the game is fair but if you are open to a big, sprawling, seafaring game ...  Read More

There are issues with the rules and not everything in the game is fair but if you are open to a big, sprawling, seafaring game and are open to playing it for weeks and weeks.  Read Less

It will cost you in terms of playing time.

It will cost you in terms of playing time.  Read Less

Then the price dropped below $12 and i bought two more copies of it.

Then the price dropped below $12 and i bought two more copies of it.  Read Less

I also love naming the islands, the ships, my city, and all the different people in the game.

I also love naming the islands, the ships, my city, and all the different people in the game.  Read Less

I get a little giddy every time i get to read from the capitan's booke.

I get a little giddy every time i get to read from the capitan's booke.  Read Less

And that was just the prologue (the beginner's learning game).

And that was just the prologue (the beginner's learning game).  Read Less

This one however is in competition with pandemic legacy as my favorite legacy game.

This one however is in competition with pandemic legacy as my favorite legacy game.  Read Less

The story isn't wonderful, but it's the twists that i enjoy experiencing (or seeing my competition agonize over).

The story isn't wonderful, but it's the twists that i enjoy experiencing (or seeing my competition agonize over).  Read Less