Ask Fakespot Chat questions about this productAlpha
Add detailed feedback
Message
Loading suggested questions
Suggested Questions
Suggested Questions
No suggested questions were found
Pros & Cons
pros
See Details
pros
See Details
Scholarly Approach
Customers are highly impressed with the scholarly approach taken by the author in examining the history and background of Mecca. The book's objective analysis and use of historical record and scientific evidence have been praised as damning to those claiming historical value to Islam, enhancing efforts for reform within the faith.
Highlights
Quality
The tradition is that all the information about them was passed along for a couple centuries by perfect oral transmission.
Psychologically, this approach just enhances townsend’s position.
Since reading tom holland’s in the shadow of the sword i was aware that much of the islamic tradition was nothing but fabricati... Read More
It is easily readable drawing you into the history of arabia and the peculiars of its peoples, trades, life, religious communit... Read More
Competitiveness
The nabatean city of petra would fit much better in all descriptions.
While one may raise an issue here or there regarding his conclusions, there is no doubting that as a historical document is far... Read More
Overview
- How are reviewers describing this item?
historical. - Our engine has profiled the reviewer patterns and has determined that there is minimal deception involved.
- Our engine has determined that the review content quality is high and informative.
- Our engine has discovered that over 90% high quality reviews are present.
- This product had a total of 128 reviews as of our last analysis date on Nov 19 2024.
Helpful InsightsBETA
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Over 50 pages of endnotes backing up his work and over 20 pages of bibliography
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
I couldn’t recommend this book highly enough
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Several scholars have been delving into this matter
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
This is peters expose on the subject
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
The nabatean city of petra would fit much better in all descriptions
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
The author even finds it possible that the black stone in the side if the kaaba may have been brought there from a holy site much further north like petra
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
No stories in the quran and hadiths can be proven by any other and independent sources
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
The argument of the book is that there is no contemporary evidence that mecca existed during the life of mohammed
Review Count History
Price History
Ask Fakespot Chat questions about this productAlpha
Add detailed feedback
Message
Loading suggested questions
Suggested Questions
Suggested Questions
No suggested questions were found