Ask Fakespot Chat questions about this productAlpha
Add detailed feedback
Message
Loading suggested questions
Suggested Questions
Suggested Questions
No suggested questions were found
Pros & Cons
Pros
A fastness, a fortress. This book shows catholicism from the eyes of an outsider. Secrets are the bane of irish families.
Lib wright is an english nurse who studied nursing under florence nightingale. In 1859, lib is sent to a small catholic village in ireland to examine the case of an eleven-year-old girl who is said to survive without food. After nearly a fortnight of ... Read More
An 11-year-old girl in ireland has been fasting for four months. A nurse arrives to see if the child is taking in any food. As the child dies, the nurse becomes increasingly aware of circumstances that have led the child to this conclusion.
Anna is a little girl who most treasured possessions involve prayer cards. She is befriended by a newspaper reporter sent there to cover the story. As she spends time with anna, an unlikely friendship develops.
Cons
No one in this book is likable. A dull story, repetitive and uneventful.
This one comes in as controlling and presumptuous," says the author. Donoghue's account of the religious fervor and secretiveness of the irish locals is heavy-handed and cliche. The tight circle of priests and doctors who perpetuated and sanctified th... Read More
Highlights
Quality
I read it eagerly and was not disappointed.
I wasn’t familiar with the actress and writer but found her voice to be wonderful.
Thankfully, i agreed with the ending, which didn’t come soon enough.
Price
Donoghue is a great author undersells her talent.
Shipping
To fast was to hold fast to emptiness, to say no and no and no again.
Packaging/appearance
I found it fascinating that anna was celebrated for not eating when ireland had come out of the potato famine not long before.
Competitiveness
It held my attention for the long flight from paris to the usa.
Overview
- How are reviewers describing this item?
good, religious, written, slow and irish. - Our engine has profiled the reviewer patterns and has determined that there is minimal deception involved.
- Our engine has determined that the review content quality is high and informative.
- Our engine has discovered that over 90% high quality reviews are present.
- This product had a total of 2,047 reviews as of our last analysis date on Sep 12 2022.
Helpful InsightsBETA
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Not sure who to recommend it to but i it is truely well written novel
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
And then there was hope it was her test and not the childs
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Maybe as a retired rn and being raised catholic i was able to relate to all sides of this story
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
I loved the setting rural ireland and the period about 1856 and learning through the personal references to the great potato famine the crimean war florence nightingale and the mode of nursing ms
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
I cant get enough of this author and am hopeful as i set off to find astray
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Our narrator is a 20someyearold young nurse trained under florence nightingale who is hired to watch an 11yearold girl everyone thinks has subsisted on nothing but water for four months
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Her gift for narrative… authentic and convincing narrative… is nothing short of aweinspiring
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
An absolute truth shows the prejudice of the english against irish catholics that they are all shiftless thriftless and hopeless
Review Count History
Price History
Ask Fakespot Chat questions about this productAlpha
Add detailed feedback
Message
Loading suggested questions
Suggested Questions
Suggested Questions
No suggested questions were found