Pros & Cons
Pros
The historical and political overview is much more accurate and trustworthy than other books written. He provides a summary of what happened, with attention to the specific methodology of bloodletting. As we gain experience in life and see how ignoran... Read More
Victor davis hanson is a professor of classics. Hanson's theme is that some six elements in the western pursuit of war have led us to our current world view. Hanson also refers to these factors in aggregate as secular rationalism. Hanson frequently ci... Read More
Victor davis hanson looks at each of the first seven victories and isolates the one aspect of western military ethos that helped * victory from the jaws of defeat. He also discusses the horrific roman debacle at cannae and discusses the aspect of wme ... Read More
Highlights
Quality
Regardless of these, which we have always seen fit to correct and change, we have given the world the most freedom it has even ... Read More
They are 1) personal freedom, which "does not begin earlier than the greeks," 2) civic militarism, in which duty calls citizens... Read More
If the 4,000 warriors of the three zulu impis had had the strength to mount one more charge, the 100 defenders of rorke's drift... Read More
Very well written with a cogent theme throughout, typical hanson analyses, and an engaging style.
Competitiveness
" in addition to salamis, 480 bc, we get gaugamela, 331 bc, cannae, 216 bc, poitiers, 732 ad, tenochtitlan, 1521, lepanto, 1571... Read More
Overview
- How are reviewers describing this item?
western, most, classical, written and past. - Our engine has profiled the reviewer patterns and has determined that there is minimal deception involved.
- Our engine has determined that the review content quality is high and informative.
- Our engine has discovered that over 90% high quality reviews are present.
- This product had a total of 50 reviews as of our last analysis date on Apr 27 2024.
Helpful InsightsBETA
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
My first encounter with victor davis hanson came between the covers of 34the western way of war infantry battle in classical greece34 in which he described the horrific bloody scrimmage that was hoplite combat
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
At the conclusion of the book he drew some far reaching conclusions with which i did not agree about the western way of war
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Not far into the chapter it was revealed that hanson was talking about the battle of tours
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Ironically every victory recounted save one came within a hairbreadth of disaster
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
The greeks at salamis nearly debated themselves into anarchy
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Parmenio was almost overwhelmed at gaugamela
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Had charles martels shield wall lost cohesion against the murderous onslaught of the saracens the franks would have suffered the fate of the housecarls at hastings and a mosque might well now stand on the site of notre dame cathedral
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Cortez came within an inch of annihilation at tenochtitlan